Disclosure: When you buy through links on our website we may earn a commission.

BCAAs vs. Protein: Which is Better for Building Muscle? What Experts Say!

If you’re new to the world of bodybuilding and supplements, you may have some questions about all of the different products to take to build muscles. You might be thinking about which one you should take. The question of BCAAS vs. Protein is a common one. What’s the difference? Which supplement is better for your exercise goals? How will you decide whether you should use BCAAs vs. proteins in a supplement? This guide will answer everything you need to know about BCAAs vs. proteins.

BCAAs vs. Protein - a steak boxing lettuce

What is BCAAs?

BCAAs are also proteins – but they are incomplete proteins. Amino acid makes proteins. BCAA stands for Branched Chain Amino Acid. BCAAs are specialized amino acids that promote lean muscle growth, improve athletic performance, and promote protein synthesis. It has a lower caloric content than whey protein. It makes them better if you cut weight while maintaining muscle. 

BCAAs are more available than whey protein and help premature fatigue when training fasted. The essential amino acids are molecules that have a chain of elements attached. The chemical function of these chains is considered to be complex. We need to understand that these three amino acids are essential for building muscle. The three branched-chain amino acids are: 

· Leucine

· Isoleucine

· Valine

BCAAs vs. Protein - supposed effect of BCAA supplementation
Supposed effects of BCAA supplementation. ALA, alanine; BCAA, branched-chain amino acids; GLN, glutamine; ↑, increase; ↓, decrease (PMC Open Access Subset)

These three blocked chained amino acids help you in your muscle growth and development. When these three amino acids are together, they help to build muscle, speed recovery from workouts, and reduce the soreness from exercise.

What Is Protein?

Well, it’s exactly what it sounds like. Proteins are macronutrients that are important for building your muscle mass. We get proteins through animal foods and plant-based foods. We can get enough protein simply from eating meat and beans. However, people who exercise regularly and athletes may need added protein in the form of supplements, shakes, or powder.  

Many trainers and fitness experts recommend taking protein in routine, especially when you are about to start workouts. It ensures that your muscles are energized. It helps to maximize your athletic performance. In addition, it repairs the muscular “microtears .”You will get aid recovery and ensure that you do not suffer from excessive soreness or muscle weakness post-workout.

BCAAs Vs. Protein Differences

The fundamental difference between BCAAs and proteins is that BCAA supplements only contain the three amino acids. While they are potent supplements for building muscle, they provide no real benefit. On the other hand, proteins provide you with the full range of amino acids that are used to build muscles. 

Proteins contain the three primary BCAAs. They naturally have the necessary amino acids to build a protein since they are entirely made proteins. Therefore, you will get BCAAs simply by eating proteins or taking protein supplements. However, every person doesn’t take proteins and BCAAs for the same reasons: different people, different choices.

Get Paid To Get Healthy With Sherri Shepherd!

A person whose primary goal is to build lean muscle mass can take BCAAs as they may be the right supplement for him. This is because the three amino acids in BCAA supplements become immediately available to the body to build muscle. On the other hand, protein has to be metabolized and broken into component amino acids. 

BCAAs contain a complete protein, so it is used to build muscle. For people training for advanced competition, for example, the direct availability of a BCAA supplement may be a better option.

Here is a video with a decisive answer in this ongoing controversy:

When to take BCAAs

People who exercise to stay fit and advanced trained athletes take BCAAs. These are some of the advantages of BCAAs as opposed to proteins. BCAAs helps to:

  • Build muscle
  • Reduce fatigue 
  • Cut down on the intensity
  • Length of muscle soreness post-workout.

These special amino acids are readily available for protein synthesis. It means BCAAs can work toward building and repairing your muscles immediately. It would be best if you took BCAAs when you:

Need to build muscle

One BCAAs, leucine, activates a specific metabolic mechanism that stimulates muscle protein synthesis. Synthesis is making muscle in the body from amino acid elements. The science suggests that taking as little as 5.5 grams of BCAAs after a resistance workout can increase muscle protein by more than 20 percent. Therefore, it appears that the best time to take BCAAs is immediately following your training workout. 

When to take protein

BCAAs and proteins overlap in nutrients. Proteins play an important role in our bodies and help to maintain them. Here are some reasons why we should use Protein.

Maintains muscle mass

Protein is preferred over BCAAs as it maintains your muscle mass. As we get older, maintaining muscle mass becomes more significant. Sometimes, the goal is to keep what you have rather than build more muscle mass. Doctors recommend taking a balanced level of protein in a day to prevent muscle loss as we get older. Taking roughly 25Grams to 30Grams of protein per meal appears sufficient to ward off muscle loss. 

Losing weight

A high-protein diet will increase your metabolism and reduce your appetite. If you don’t take interest in building muscle but aim to lose weight, then proteins might help you. Protein is one of the essential nutrients that help to lose weight. Moreover, it also curbs your appetite by reducing the production of a hormone called ghrelin. This hormone makes you feel hungry. 

Protein equally helps your body boost levels of other hormones that reduce appetite. Even a high-protein snack between meals will reduce your need to eat. If you take a protein supplement, you will not feel as hungry and are less likely to overeat and fill up on snacks.

Build muscle

Protein contains everything necessary to build muscle. Since muscle is made primarily of protein, no doubt, taking the protein helps you build muscles. If you are working out or training competitively, you will naturally break down muscle tissue as part of the process. An anabolic window is a time frame in which people take protein supplements 15-60 minutes after exercise. 

You can take most out of the nutrients in this optimum time to increase the benefits of your exercise. However, many experts say that you can take your protein supplement any time up to two hours after a workout. It will provide you with all the amino acids you need to build muscle mass. In any case, protein is undoubtedly great for building muscle. In terms of your overall goals, it may be better to take BCAAs because they are readily assimilable for making muscle protein. 

Benefits of BCAAs and Proteins

BCAAs help build muscles, benefit from liver disease, Reduce fatigue, Reduce soreness, and prevent muscle loss. While on the other hand, protein helps us reduce muscle soreness, prevent muscle loss, and give added muscles and nutrition.

Protein Basics for Gaining Muscle

Protein is an essential nutrient used to build and repair all the tissues in your body, including muscles. If you eat not enough protein dose, your body and muscles can’t function properly.

BCAA or Protein after exercise

You might take BCAAs with your protein shortly after exercising. However, it would be better to consume BCAA supplements before and during exercise to fuel your muscles and preserve glycogen stores. Look for a protein blend with a 2:1:1 BCAA ratio—10 grams of BCAAs per serving, five of which are leucine.

Wrapping things up

When we talk about BCAAs, it goes straight to the metabolic processes. It repairs and builds muscle tissue. Proteins have many advantages for people whose primary interests are nutrition and preventing muscle loss. It helps older people who require extra nutrition benefit from taking protein supplements. 

When you consider the supplements to help you build your muscle and make it possible to keep going in your training and exercises, the decision often comes down to BCAAs vs. proteins. Whether you are interested in high-intensity exercise or general fitness, BCAAs and proteins can offer what you need. It depends upon your primary goals. 

Both BCAAs and proteins might help build muscle and reduce soreness and fatigue. On the other hand, athletes and fitness enthusiasts may prefer a BCAA supplement since they get nutrition from dietary sources. 

Protein is the winner to building muscles 

When it comes to BCAAs and muscle growth, very little research and evidence for any benefits are found. As mentioned before, BCAAs fall short there, too. All scientific research was reviewed and concluded that there are no apparent benefits from consuming additional BCAAs and your regular diet. 

If you want to build muscle, you require essential amino acids. Familiar protein sources already provide all of them, and BCAAs alone have little effect. Scientifically, you can boost your muscles growth by adding protein to your diet. It adds to your total daily protein intake and max your gains. If the main goal is building muscle, then choose the protein. In other cases, both BCAAs and proteins can help give you actual results in your training and workouts.

I love it if you ask me to write about something you like to know about health. Let me know in the comments if you want to know about any review, supplements, or exercise.

Join the 5 Day Get Moving Challenge to Unlock The Keys for a Healthy Lifestyle By Getting Up and Moving Today

Photo of author

Noble Woods III

My name is Noble, I have a passion for fitness and all things related to healthy living. My mission is to share my story and help those who wish to make a healthy change. Follow me on socials.

Leave a Comment